Guide to Oil Paint vs Acrylic (2024)

Introduction

Oil and acrylic paints are indispensable mediums in the art world. Each has its own distinct properties, histories, and benefits and disadvantages while working with them to create a painting. Oil paint's illustrious history as being the premiere medium used by the most talented artists of past centuries has made it attractive to those who want to use its inherent depth and texture to create their own masterpieces. Acrylic paint's relatively new formation and versatility has given it a reputation for being one of the main paints of the modern world. Famous artists like Vincent van Gogh and Andy Warhol have used these respective paints in their most celebrated works.

About Oil Painting

Oil paint consists of tiny particles of pigment which are mixed and suspended in thinner, linseed oil, a stabilizer and a drying agent. Their introduction in the 1200s in England led to their use in decorative painting, which in turn resulted in their incorporation into legitimate artistic painting by the 1400s. Popular with artists for hundreds of years, oil paints have been the go-to medium for some of the most renowned painters in history. Oil paints are notorious for taking a very long time to dry; a painting created with oils can require as much as a few months to produce a completely dry surface. Many artists take advantage of this slow-drying process to add to their paintings several times over, combining layers which contribute to texture within the work. Oil paints are suspected of losing color over time.

About Acrylic Painting

Acrylic paint consists of pigment that uses mineral spirits and acrylic resin for mixture and suspension. In contrast to oil paints, acrylic paints are extremely fast-drying and, in some cases, require only 60 seconds to provide a dry surface. Many acrylics are noted as drying down at a slightly darker color. These paints were first made widely available in the mid 20th century, with many pop artists adopting them as their preferred medium. Water can be used to dilute acrylic paint, adding variability to the same color in depth and texture. It should be noted, however, that once dried, acrylic paint becomes completely resistant to water and dilution. Acrylic paint's versatility through dilution means that a painting created with it can look like it were made with wispy water colors or intense oil paints. Artists interested in experiencing the best of both the oil and acrylic paint worlds can use certain products to take advantage of acrylic paint's low toxicity, while making it dry and behave like an oil paint. Use of these products can also make the act of blending two different acrylic colors easy, as mixing acrylics in their natural state can be difficult.

The Difference Between the Two

It's important to realize that while acrylic paint can be tamed to behave like oil paint, both types of paints have their distinct advantages and disadvantages, as well as distinguishing features and limitations. Each require a mastery of paint-specific techniques. Acrylics are fairly new paints that were first made available in the 1950s, while oil paints have existed for hundreds of years. Oil paints are more transparent than the richer acrylic paints, but water or gels can be added to acrylics to make them more transparent. For painters interested in texture, oil paints are usually used, though special gels added to acrylics can make them capable of providing interesting textural possibilities. If you're a new painter, it might not matter so much which paint you decide to use. Acrylics are usually more inexpensive and longer-lasting than oil paints. Your choice may depend on your comfort with each paint's drying and dilution properties.

Famous Painters

Both oil and acrylic paints have been used to create some of the most memorable artistic works in the world. Some famous artists who have worked with oil paint include Rembrandt, Vincent van Gogh and Claude Monet. Rembrandt's "Bust of an Old Man" can be found at Tiroler Landesmuseen in Austria, Van Gogh's "Portrait of Dr. Gachet" has disappeared from the public eye, and pieces of Monet's collection of paintings titled "Water Lilies" are simultaneously on display at various museums around the world, including the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. Any Warhol, David Hockney and Roy Lichtenstein are known for their use of acrylics. Warhol's "Marilyn Diptych", Hockney's "Mr. and Mrs. Clark and Percy", and Lichtenstein's "Whaam!" can be found hanging at the Tate. Despite their different mediums, these paintings' commonality of greatness make them shining examples of the possibilities of both types of paints.

Guide to Oil Paint vs Acrylic (2024)

FAQs

Guide to Oil Paint vs Acrylic? ›

Acrylic paints are manufactured like oils but without oil. They're water-based, which makes them safer to use. They're a great option for beginners. You can gain practice and work on techniques before moving on to oil paints.

Which is better for beginners, oil or acrylic paint? ›

Acrylic paints are manufactured like oils but without oil. They're water-based, which makes them safer to use. They're a great option for beginners. You can gain practice and work on techniques before moving on to oil paints.

Do professional painters use oil or acrylic? ›

Popular with artists for hundreds of years, oil paints have been the go-to medium for some of the most renowned painters in history.

What is an important advantage of acrylic paint over oil paint? ›

It's fast-drying

If you want to produce your paintings at speed, acrylic paints are an excellent choice. Acrylics can be dry to the touch in 20 minutes, while oils can take days to reach that stage.

How to tell the difference between acrylic and oil paintings? ›

Hold the painting at an angle and look at the paint's texture on the canvas. If it's highly textured and looks very layered, the painting is likely an oil painting. Acrylic paint dries smooth and somewhat rubbery-looking (unless an additive has been used to give the paint a thicker texture).

What is a disadvantage of using acrylic paint instead of oil paint? ›

Disadvantages: because acrylic paints dry quickly they cannot be easily blended to create the 'wet in wet' technique that is popular with oil paints.

Why do people prefer oil over acrylic? ›

Oil paints are known as being more durable than acrylic paintings so many people choose them for this reason alone. However, there are some cases where acrylics may be preferable such as those who use these types of paint indoors as well as outdoors due to its quick drying time compared to oils which take much longer.

What sells for more acrylic or oil paintings? ›

Art collectors at our Gulfport gallery often ask if oil paintings or acrylic paintings are more valuable. However, the type of paint used does not determine the actual value of a work. It depends on several factors like the quality of the artwork, the work's size, and the artist's reputation.

Do oil paintings look better than acrylic? ›

This ultimately is a subjective question, but at the same time, it might be safe to say that, on the whole, oil paintings typically just plain look better than acrylic paintings do. If you're just getting into painting though, it might in fact be a good idea to start with acrylics – I'm glad I took the path I did.

Why do painters prefer oil paint? ›

Oil paints blend well with each other, making subtle variations of colour possible as well as more easily creating details of light and shadow. They can also be diluted with turpentine or other thinning agents. A heavily diluted layer dries relatively quickly, being tack-free in a few days.

What are the disadvantages of oil painting? ›

One disadvantage is their strong odor. Oil paints also take longer than latex paints to dry compared, which can be a significant inconvenience for anyone on a strict timeline. Finally, oil-based paints tend to cost more than latex paints upfront, making them less ideal for anyone on a budget.

Did Bob Ross use oil or acrylic? ›

The iconic art style of Bob Ross is most easily achieved by using oil paints, but not everyone can afford to spend $11 per color on Bob's licensed paints—especially when he uses over ten colors per painting. For half the cost, use acrylic paints instead.

What is the weakness of acrylic paint? ›

One of the disadvantages is that acrylics are available in fewer colours, there's no denying the remarkable color variety of oil paints and the subtlety of watercolour. Another is the fact that when used thickly acrylics dry to a glossy, smooth finish.

Which is more expensive, acrylic or oil paint? ›

Yes, oil paintings can be more expensive to produce than acrylic paintings. The paints themselves are more costly for artists to buy. Acrylic paints are water-based paints that dry quickly with a glossy finish. Acrylics are less expensive than oil paints, which makes them a good choice for artists on a budget.

How to begin oil painting? ›

Start by adding areas of shadow and light, fill in large areas with color, then work patiently, laying on more and more intense layers of color. You need to follow the golden rule of oil painting: painting "thick on thin" .

What kind of paint is best for beginners? ›

So if you want to learn about composition, form, color matching, color harmony, and so on, a more forgiving medium such as oils, or acrylics might be your best choice.

Is oil painting good for beginners? ›

With oil paints, thankfully, it's a much easier process; you can simply scrape back the paint with a palette knife (or, if the paint layer is thin, wipe it off with a rag) and paint over it. Because oil paints are more opaque, it's much easier to paint over mistakes, even if you're painting white onto a dark color.

Is acrylic paint best for beginners? ›

Personally, I think Acrylics would be a good starting place for you. They can be used like oils if used straight from the tube. They can be thinned with water and used like watercolor if you want. The only drawback to Acrylics for the beginner is that they dry so fast they require an extender.

Which lasts longer, acrylic or oil paint? ›

Which Lasts Longer Acrylic or Oil Paint? Acrylics are water-based, which means they dry quickly but do not last as long as oils. Oil paints take a while to dry but can last for centuries if kept in a safe environment away from the light.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jerrold Considine

Last Updated:

Views: 6285

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jerrold Considine

Birthday: 1993-11-03

Address: Suite 447 3463 Marybelle Circles, New Marlin, AL 20765

Phone: +5816749283868

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Air sports, Sand art, Electronics, LARPing, Baseball, Book restoration, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Jerrold Considine, I am a combative, cheerful, encouraging, happy, enthusiastic, funny, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.